Every cleanup job eventually runs into the same question: who pays for it? On the ground, the answer is usually settled. A town collects trash through taxes, fees or a contract with a hauler, and businesses pay to have their own dumpsters emptied. In orbit, the answer is still being worked out. This page walks through the main candidates, in plain English: governments, satellite operators, insurers, and the rules that tie them together. It also explains why we think the question matters for anyone planning a debris-removal service, including The Incognito.
We want to be upfront about one thing. We are not lawyers or economists, and nothing here is legal or financial advice. We have tried to stick to what public sources actually say and to link to them so you can read them yourself.
Why "who pays" is the hard part
Most people agree that debris in orbit is a problem. Our guide to Kessler syndrome explains how collisions can create more fragments, which raise the odds of more collisions. Our look at active debris removal shows that real teams are already learning how to approach and capture old hardware. The technology is hard, but it is moving.
The money is harder. In March 2023, NASA's Office of Technology, Policy, and Strategy published a Cost and Benefit Analysis of Orbital Debris Remediation. It notes that the reasons usually given for cleanup, such as safety, responsibility to other operators and keeping space usable for future generations, are valid. But it says that, given the large upfront costs and the long wait for benefits, those reasons "do not appear to be sufficient to incentivize immediate action."
Anyone who has run a hauling business will recognize that. Everyone wants the street clean. Fewer people want to be the one who writes the check, especially when the benefit is spread across the whole neighborhood.
Option one: governments
The NASA report spends real time on this. It describes two common opinions in the U.S. government: that companies will build a business case for cleanup on their own, and that private companies create most of the debris and so should pay to remove it. The report says, carefully, that it found both narratives "weakly supported" by its own findings.
Its reasoning is simple to follow. In the cleanup scenarios NASA modeled, the benefits were almost entirely reductions in risk to satellite operators, not direct cost savings. And the risk reduction for any single operator was likely too small to get that operator to pay for removal by itself. The report's conclusion for those scenarios is that "governments may be the most appropriate actors to address the collective action problem."
That is a familiar pattern. A single household does not pay to keep a whole county's roads clear of litter. The county does, because the benefit is shared. The report is also careful to say it is not ruling out private business cases. It simply did not find them in the two scenarios it studied.
Governments are already acting as early customers. ESA's ClearSpace-1 mission is planned to capture and bring down ESA's own old PROBA-1 satellite. When ESA signed the original contract in 2020, it described it as an €86 million contract "to purchase a unique service: the first removal of an item of space debris from orbit." The mission team has changed since then. ESA now lists OHB SE leading an industrial team with ClearSpace. But the idea of an agency buying removal as a service, rather than building everything in-house, is worth noticing. In Japan, the space agency JAXA is listed as the customer for Astroscale's ADRAS-J inspection mission, part of JAXA's Commercial Removal of Debris Demonstration project.
Option two: the operators who own the hardware
On the ground, the person who fills the dumpster pays to have it emptied. It is natural to ask whether the same should be true in orbit.
There is a real legal basis for responsibility, though it works differently than a trash bill. The 1972 Convention on International Liability for Damage Caused by Space Objects, managed by the United Nations Office for Outer Space Affairs, says a launching State is "absolutely liable to pay compensation for damage caused by its space objects on the surface of the Earth or to aircraft, and liable for damage due to its faults in space." In plain terms, damage on the ground or to aircraft is covered no matter whose fault it was, while damage in space depends on fault.
Two things stand out. First, the convention speaks to countries, not directly to companies. Countries then decide how to license and hold their own operators responsible. Second, it is about paying for damage after it happens, not paying to remove debris before it causes harm.
The NASA report points to this as the place where a private business case might live. It says it did not model the liability an operator carries for the debris it has created, and it calls that liability "likely the basis of the value proposition for a private company to purchase debris remediation services, absent new regulatory incentives." In other words, an operator with a dead satellite in a busy orbit may one day decide it is cheaper to pay for removal than to carry the risk.
The report also notes something we found encouraging. Citing ESA data, it says that over the decade beginning in 2010, commercial operators placed their defunct spacecraft into orbits that met the older 25-year disposal guideline at a substantially higher rate than civil and military operators. Many companies are already trying to do the right thing with their own hardware.
Option three: insurers
Some people expect insurance to drive cleanup. The thinking goes like this: more debris means more risk, more risk means higher premiums, and higher premiums would give operators a reason to pay for removal.
The NASA report looked at that and was cautious. It says some operators buy insurance against the risk that their system fails, and that rising risk can raise premiums. But its initial assessment suggested that orbital debris "appears to have a limited influence on why insurance policies are purchased and how premiums are set." So, at least as of 2023, NASA did not see insurance as a strong push toward cleanup.
That could change if collisions become more common or if insurers start to price debris risk more directly. We are not predicting that. We are only noting that insurers are one of the parties a cleanup service would want to talk with, because they see the cost of losses up close.
Option four: rules that make cleanup part of the plan
Rules are the other lever. They don't pay for anything directly, but they decide whose problem a dead satellite becomes. Our explainer on the FCC 5-year deorbit rule covers one example: a U.S. rule that shortens how long many low-orbit satellites can stay up after their missions end.
Rules like that mostly prevent new debris. They don't pick up the old rocket bodies and satellites already in orbit, which is the part of the job that needs a truck. But they do change the math. When an operator must clear its orbit within a set time, a satellite that fails early becomes a problem the operator has to solve, and paying for a removal service becomes one possible way to solve it. ESA's own debris rules work in a similar direction, and ESA is preparing satellites to be easier to grab later, as our active debris removal page describes.
What this means for a cleanup service
Put together, the picture looks something like a town that is still deciding how to fund trash pickup. Today, governments are the clearest buyers, through demonstration missions and contracts. Operators may become buyers as rules tighten and as they weigh the liability of their own dead hardware. Insurers are watching, but public analysis so far suggests they are not driving demand yet.
For a hauler, that kind of market is not strange. Many waste companies start with a municipal contract and add commercial customers over time. The lesson John Arwood brings from that world, which we wrote about in From Garbage Routes to Orbit, is that a route has to pay for itself. A service that can make many stops, rather than one, spreads its cost over more customers, whoever those customers turn out to be.
The Incognito is a concept, not a flying prototype, and the design is patent pending. We are not claiming any agency, operator or insurer has reviewed it or agreed to pay for it. You can read the concept itself on The Concept page.
Talk with us
If you work on space policy, insurance, satellite operations or in-space servicing and have thoughts on how cleanup should be funded, we would genuinely like to hear them. If your organization is interested in acquisition, licensing or a development partnership, please visit For Partners & Acquirers.
Frequently asked questions
Who is legally responsible for space debris?
Under the 1972 Liability Convention, the launching State is absolutely liable for damage its space objects cause on the Earth's surface or to aircraft, and liable for damage in space when it is at fault. Countries then license and oversee their own operators. This is general information, not legal advice.
Does anyone pay for debris removal today?
Yes, mostly space agencies so far. ESA contracted for the ClearSpace-1 removal mission, and JAXA is the customer for Astroscale's ADRAS-J inspection mission under its debris removal demonstration project.
Will insurance pay for space cleanup?
Not directly, as far as public analysis shows. NASA's 2023 report found that orbital debris appears to have a limited influence on how space insurance is bought and priced.
Does the craft have other uses?
The Incognito is a versatile platform with defense applications available to qualified government partners on request.